XP Workstations & VLANs



Hello all! I am the desktop administrator for a school district. Our
network admin had some Cisco consultants come in last week and
implement VLANs. They segmented off the following:
1. Servers (mostly W2k3)
2. Elementary
3. Middle school
4. High school
5. District offices

I've never worked in a VLAN environment before (but I have worked in a
WAN environment, so I'm hoping that it's going to turn out to be
similar). I have had a lot of trouble getting Ghost to work since they
did this, but I've been able to work around that issue. However, I'm
in quite a pickle now with some XP workstations, and this is VERY
bizarre. Unfortunately, neither the network admin nor the consultants
have a clue about this issue. After I ghosted the workstations (in the
Elementary vlan), they came up with the Windows setup as normal. I was
able to join them all to the domain during setup, except for one where
sloppy typing led to an incorrectly-entered password, and it wasn't
joined. All of the machines rebooted at the end of their setup.

The 5 computers I ghosted are mobile carts, so for the ones that
joined, I unplugged them and wheeled them away. The last I logged onto
locally and tried to manually join it to the domain.. it said that it
couldn't find the domain controller. It could release/renew a DHCP
address, but could only ping within its own subnet; it could not ping
past its gateway. And because the DNS server is in a different vlan,
it couldn't do any resolutions. I pulled back one of the finished
workstations, thinking perhaps it was a cable or jack issue. I plugged
it back into the next jack, and it too could no longer ping outside of
its gateway. I went into the hub room and plugged the second
workstation into a different switch. Still no resolution.

My workstation is in the District office vlan, and I could ping the two
workstations, and control them through VNC. I gave the workstations
static IP addresses and manually entered the Gateway & DNS info, but
again.. no dice. It's as if the firewall is turned on, but it is not.

At this point, this is Day 3 of a project that should've taken me one.
Because of these VLANs, I can't seem to get any work done anymore. So
I passed the buck onto the network admin, and he called the
consultants. They worked on it for another hour, mostly trying all of
the things I already have.

It's been a while since I pulled out of the networking side and moved
over to my home in desktops & training, but since no one else has an
answer it's up to me to find it. The only thing left that I can think
of is the fact that I don't think there's a master browser in each
vlan. Is that a necessity with an NT5-based network? Fortunately the
teachers and students are all out on vacation, but we have about 2/3 of
our elementary clients still using W98. I dread to turn those on.

So... if anyone out there can offer me a few pearls of wisdom, I'm all
ears!! Thanks!

--Melissa

.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: My Network Places
    ... > the servers in that VLAN as the master browser, give it a reboot and leave ... >> DNS Servers(Also domain controllers) ... >>> Workstations are using DHCP ...
    (microsoft.public.windows.server.general)
  • Re: My Network Places
    ... the servers in that VLAN as the master browser, give it a reboot and leave ... > DNS Servers(Also domain controllers) ... >> Workstations are using DHCP ...
    (microsoft.public.windows.server.general)
  • Re: DHCP Configuration
    ... Set reservations in DHCP by mac addresses. ... make reservations for the 10 workstations, ... > go to VLAN2 and plug in and receive a dynamic address from the VLAN. ...
    (microsoft.public.windows.server.setup)