Re: Problem with NT4 domain trusting W2003 domain



Hi Franz,

I'm sorry to hear that my suggestions didn't help. But I'm glad to hear
that you have workaround for your customer.

I have delivery your problem in an internal disscussion group and I will
let you know if there are any further information.

Best regards,

Vincent Xu
Microsoft Online Partner Support

Get Secure! - www.microsoft.com/security


--------------------
| From: "Franz Schenk" <franz.schenkNOSPAM@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
| References: <u0xnOOHjFHA.3936@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
<gEXo4hRjFHA.588@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
<uiWYSUSjFHA.3960@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
<y9WORNcjFHA.940@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
| Subject: Re: Problem with NT4 domain trusting W2003 domain
| Date: Thu, 21 Jul 2005 10:54:09 +0200
| Lines: 856
| X-Priority: 3
| X-MSMail-Priority: Normal
| X-Newsreader: Microsoft Outlook Express 6.00.2900.2527
| X-MimeOLE: Produced By Microsoft MimeOLE V6.00.2900.2527
| X-RFC2646: Format=Flowed; Original
| Message-ID: <eXtcdGdjFHA.3316@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
| Newsgroups: microsoft.public.windows.server.migration
| NNTP-Posting-Host: mail.fitit.ch 81.6.6.11
| Path: TK2MSFTNGXA01.phx.gbl!TK2MSFTNGP08.phx.gbl!TK2MSFTNGP14.phx.gbl
| Xref: TK2MSFTNGXA01.phx.gbl
microsoft.public.windows.server.migration:11340
| X-Tomcat-NG: microsoft.public.windows.server.migration
|
| Hi Vincent
|
| Thank you very much for your help. Unfortunately, still the same problem,
| although it's a good idea to disable SMB signing (we always have problems
| with that since Microsoft enabled this options by default..). I also have
| implemented the settings you suggested in the "default domain controller
| GPO" and not in the local GPO, and verified with GPMC that they are
| successfully applied. A html report of the effective GPO settings is in
the
| attached ZIP file.
|
| Although I don't understand why I have this problem (seems not logical to
| me), we have a workaround in the customer site (installed VNC Remote
Control
| Tool on the NT4 machine, and the Exchange 5.5 Admin Tools work fine). And
we
| can share NT4 ressources for the W2003 domain users by entering all ACL
| information manually.
| If you have another idea, I'm very glad know about it (according to the
| security eventlog on the Windows 2003 DC, NT4 tries to logon with the
| <NT4-domain>\Administrator account on the Windows 2003 DC for retrieving
the
| list of Windows 2003 groups and users, thats the point I don't
understand).
| But I think that there is no need that you have too much work for us for
| this issue.
|
| Thank you again for the excellent support!
| Franz
|
| "Vincent Xu [MSFT]" <v-xuwen@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> schrieb im Newsbeitrag
| news:y9WORNcjFHA.940@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
| > Hi Franz,
| >
| > Thank you for your update.
| >
| > I have performed further research on your issue. For your situation (in
a
| > mix domain environment and the issue didn't occur in two way trust), I
| > suspect there are some settings in security options caused this problem,
| > please check:
| >
| > 1. Run "gpedit.msc"
| > 2. Expand to "Computer configuration\Windows Settings\local
| > policies\Security options\"
| > 3. Check following policies:
| >
| > "Microsoft Network Server: Digitally sign communications" set to
disable.
| > "Network access: Allow anonymous SID/Name translation" set to enable.
| > "Network access: Do not allow anonymous enumeration of SAM accounts"
set
| > to
| > disable.
| > "Network access: Do not allow anonymous enumeration of SAM accounts and
| > shares" set to disable.
| > "Network access: Restrict anonymous access to Named Pipes and Shares"
set
| > to disable
| >
| > I hope the suggestions can helps.
| >
| > Best regards,
| >
| > Vincent Xu
| > Microsoft Online Partner Support
| >
| > Get Secure! - www.microsoft.com/security
| >
| >
| > --------------------
| > | From: "Franz Schenk" <franz.schenkNOSPAM@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
| > | References: <u0xnOOHjFHA.3936@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
| > <gEXo4hRjFHA.588@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
| > | Subject: Re: Problem with NT4 domain trusting W2003 domain
| > | Date: Wed, 20 Jul 2005 14:19:06 +0200
| > | Lines: 530
| > | X-Priority: 3
| > | X-MSMail-Priority: Normal
| > | X-Newsreader: Microsoft Outlook Express 6.00.2900.2527
| > | X-RFC2646: Format=Flowed; Original
| > | X-MimeOLE: Produced By Microsoft MimeOLE V6.00.2900.2527
| > | Message-ID: <uiWYSUSjFHA.3960@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
| > | Newsgroups: microsoft.public.windows.server.migration
| > | NNTP-Posting-Host: mail.fitit.ch 81.6.6.11
| > | Path: TK2MSFTNGXA01.phx.gbl!TK2MSFTNGP08.phx.gbl!TK2MSFTNGP12.phx.gbl
| > | Xref: TK2MSFTNGXA01.phx.gbl
| > microsoft.public.windows.server.migration:11324
| > | X-Tomcat-NG: microsoft.public.windows.server.migration
| > |
| > | Hi Vincent
| > |
| > | Thank you so far for the support! But it still doesn't work. What I've
| > done
| > | so far:
| > |
| > | - Recreated the trust according KB 325874: Same result. I can choose
the
| > | Windows 2003 domain in the ACL Editor, but instead of displaying the
| > user
| > | list of the Windows 2003 domain, I'm still getting the Error "Unable
to
| > | browse the selected domain because the following error occured:
Access
| > is
| > | denied".
| > |
| > | - Accessing ressources on the NT4 Server from the Windows 2003 domain
| > work
| > | as it should (Even with the error message in the NT4 ACL Editor, it's
| > | possible to add an ACL Entry by writing the username manually)
| > |
| > | - When adding a two way trust, the problem does not occur! It's
possible
| > to
| > | browse the Windows 2003 domain in the NT4 ACL Editor.
| > |
| > | I've tested this with two VM's on our Virtual Server, but the reason
for
| > | that is because we have the same problem in a customer location with
an
| > NT4
| > | domain trusting a Windows 2003 domain. Granting access to files on the
| > NT4
| > | servers is possible by manually entering user/group names in the ACL
| > Editor.
| > | But the problem we have in the cusomer site is that there is Exchange
| > 5.5
| > | running in the NT4 domain. Despite we granted Admin rights to a
Windows
| > 2003
| > | user to the exchange 5.5 organisation, we are getting access denied
| > errors
| > | when running Exchange 5.5 Admin with the Windows 2003 user.
| > | Before digging into Exchange, I want to be sure that the trust is ok,
| > and
| > | the behaviour we have is wrong in my opinion. It should be possible to
| > | browse the Windows 2003 Users in the NT4 ACL Editor even with a one
way
| > | trust (NT4 --> Windows 2003).
| > |
| > | Attached gplog.txt at the end of this message
| > | Thank you in advance for any further advice!
| > | Franz
| > | -----------------------
| > |
| > |
| > | Microsoft (R) Windows (R) Operating System Group Policy Result tool
v2.0
| > | Copyright (C) Microsoft Corp. 1981-2001
| > |
| > | Created On 20.07.2005 at 13:36:32
| > |
| > |
| > |
| > | RSOP data for STADTBIEL\Administrator on GHOSTSRVBIEL : Logging Mode
| > | ---------------------------------------------------------------------
| > |
| > | OS Type: Microsoft(R) Windows(R) Server 2003,
| > Enterprise
| > | Edition
| > | OS Configuration: Primary Domain Controller
| > | OS Version: 5.2.3790
| > | Terminal Server Mode: Remote Administration
| > | Site Name: Default-First-Site-Name
| > | Roaming Profile:
| > | Local Profile: C:\Documents and Settings\Administrator
| > | Connected over a slow link?: No
| > |
| > |
| > | COMPUTER SETTINGS
| > | ------------------
| > | CN=GHOSTSRVBIEL,OU=Domain Controllers,DC=stadtbiel,DC=local
| > | Last time Group Policy was applied: 20.07.2005 at 13:32:39
| > | Group Policy was applied from: ghostsrvbiel.stadtbiel.local
| > | Group Policy slow link threshold: 500 kbps
| > | Domain Name: STADTBIEL
| > | Domain Type: Windows 2000
| > |
| > | Applied Group Policy Objects
| > | -----------------------------
| > | Default Domain Controllers Policy
| > | 1stSW
| > | Default Domain Policy
| > |
| > | The following GPOs were not applied because they were filtered out
| > |
-------------------------------------------------------------------
| > | Local Group Policy
| > | Filtering: Not Applied (Empty)
| > |
| > | The computer is a part of the following security groups
| > | -------------------------------------------------------
| > | BUILTIN\Administrators
| > | Everyone
| > | BUILTIN\Users
| > | BUILTIN\Pre-Windows 2000 Compatible Access
| > | Windows Authorization Access Group
| > | NT AUTHORITY\NETWORK
| > | NT AUTHORITY\Authenticated Users
| > | This Organization
| > | GHOSTSRVBIEL$
| > | Exchange Domain Servers
| > | Domain Controllers
| > | NT AUTHORITY\ENTERPRISE DOMAIN CONTROLLERS
| > | Exchange Enterprise Servers
| > |
| > | Resultant Set Of Policies for Computer
| > | ---------------------------------------
| > |
| > | Software Installations
| > | ----------------------
| > | N/A
| > |
| > | Startup Scripts
| > | ---------------
| > | N/A
| > |
| > | Shutdown Scripts
| > | ----------------
| > | N/A
| > |
| > | Account Policies
| > | ----------------
| > | GPO: Default Domain Policy
| > | Policy: MaxServiceAge
| > | Computer Setting: 600
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Policy
| > | Policy: MaxTicketAge
| > | Computer Setting: 10
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Policy
| > | Policy: MinimumPasswordAge
| > | Computer Setting: 1
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Policy
| > | Policy: PasswordHistorySize
| > | Computer Setting: 24
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Policy
| > | Policy: MaxClockSkew
| > | Computer Setting: 5
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Policy
| > | Policy: MinimumPasswordLength
| > | Computer Setting: 5
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Policy
| > | Policy: LockoutBadCount
| > | Computer Setting: N/A
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Policy
| > | Policy: MaximumPasswordAge
| > | Computer Setting: 42
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Policy
| > | Policy: MaxRenewAge
| > | Computer Setting: 7
| > |
| > | Audit Policy
| > | ------------
| > | GPO: Default Domain Controllers Policy
| > | Policy: AuditPolicyChange
| > | Computer Setting: Success
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Controllers Policy
| > | Policy: AuditPrivilegeUse
| > | Computer Setting: No Auditing
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Controllers Policy
| > | Policy: AuditDSAccess
| > | Computer Setting: Success
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Controllers Policy
| > | Policy: AuditAccountLogon
| > | Computer Setting: Success, Failure
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Controllers Policy
| > | Policy: AuditObjectAccess
| > | Computer Setting: No Auditing
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Controllers Policy
| > | Policy: AuditAccountManage
| > | Computer Setting: Success, Failure
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Controllers Policy
| > | Policy: AuditLogonEvents
| > | Computer Setting: Success, Failure
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Controllers Policy
| > | Policy: AuditProcessTracking
| > | Computer Setting: No Auditing
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Controllers Policy
| > | Policy: AuditSystemEvents
| > | Computer Setting: Success
| > |
| > | User Rights
| > | -----------
| > | GPO: Default Domain Controllers Policy
| > | Policy: MachineAccountPrivilege
| > | Computer Setting: Authenticated Users
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Controllers Policy
| > | Policy: DenyNetworkLogonRight
| > | Computer Setting: STADTBIEL\SUPPORT_388945a0
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Controllers Policy
| > | Policy: RestorePrivilege
| > | Computer Setting: STADTBIEL\Administrator
| > | Server Operators
| > | Backup Operators
| > | Administrators
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Controllers Policy
| > | Policy: TcbPrivilege
| > | Computer Setting: STADTBIEL\Administrator
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Controllers Policy
| > | Policy: SystemProfilePrivilege
| > | Computer Setting: Administrators
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Controllers Policy
| > | Policy: DenyServiceLogonRight
| > | Computer Setting: N/A
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Controllers Policy
| > | Policy: ServiceLogonRight
| > | Computer Setting: NETWORK SERVICE
| > | STADTBIEL\Administrator
| > | BUILTIN
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Controllers Policy
| > | Policy: UndockPrivilege
| > | Computer Setting: Administrators
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Controllers Policy
| > | Policy: CreatePermanentPrivilege
| > | Computer Setting: N/A
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Controllers Policy
| > | Policy: AuditPrivilege
| > | Computer Setting: STADTBIEL\Administrator
| > | NETWORK SERVICE
| > | LOCAL SERVICE
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Controllers Policy
| > | Policy: TakeOwnershipPrivilege
| > | Computer Setting: Administrators
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Controllers Policy
| > | Policy: CreatePagefilePrivilege
| > | Computer Setting: Administrators
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Controllers Policy
| > | Policy: EnableDelegationPrivilege
| > | Computer Setting: Administrators
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Controllers Policy
| > | Policy: DebugPrivilege
| > | Computer Setting: Administrators
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Controllers Policy
| > | Policy: SystemTimePrivilege
| > | Computer Setting: Server Operators
| > | Administrators
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Controllers Policy
| > | Policy: DenyBatchLogonRight
| > | Computer Setting: N/A
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Controllers Policy
| > | Policy: BackupPrivilege
| > | Computer Setting: Server Operators
| > | Backup Operators
| > | Administrators
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Controllers Policy
| > | Policy: CreateTokenPrivilege
| > | Computer Setting: N/A
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Controllers Policy
| > | Policy: ChangeNotifyPrivilege
| > | Computer Setting: Pre-Windows 2000 Compatible Access
| > | Authenticated Users
| > | Administrators
| > | Everyone
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Controllers Policy
| > | Policy: SyncAgentPrivilege
| > | Computer Setting: N/A
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Controllers Policy
| > | Policy: ProfileSingleProcessPrivilege
| > | Computer Setting: Administrators
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Controllers Policy
| > | Policy: LoadDriverPrivilege
| > | Computer Setting: Print Operators
| > | Administrators
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Controllers Policy
| > | Policy: InteractiveLogonRight
| > | Computer Setting: Print Operators
| > | Server Operators
| > | Account Operators
| > | Backup Operators
| > | Administrators
| > | STADTBIEL\IUSR_GHOSTSRVBIEL
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Controllers Policy
| > | Policy: RemoteShutdownPrivilege
| > | Computer Setting: Server Operators
| > | Administrators
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Controllers Policy
| > | Policy: IncreaseBasePriorityPrivilege
| > | Computer Setting: Administrators
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Controllers Policy
| > | Policy: NetworkLogonRight
| > | Computer Setting: Pre-Windows 2000 Compatible Access
| > | ENTERPRISE DOMAIN CONTROLLERS
| > | Authenticated Users
| > | Administrators
| > | Everyone
| > | STADTBIEL\IWAM_GHOSTSRVBIEL
| > | STADTBIEL\IUSR_GHOSTSRVBIEL
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Controllers Policy
| > | Policy: LockMemoryPrivilege
| > | Computer Setting: N/A
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Controllers Policy
| > | Policy: ShutdownPrivilege
| > | Computer Setting: Print Operators
| > | Server Operators
| > | Backup Operators
| > | Administrators
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Controllers Policy
| > | Policy: SecurityPrivilege
| > | Computer Setting: STADTBIEL\Exchange Enterprise
Servers
| > | Administrators
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Controllers Policy
| > | Policy: AssignPrimaryTokenPrivilege
| > | Computer Setting: NETWORK SERVICE
| > | LOCAL SERVICE
| > | STADTBIEL\IWAM_GHOSTSRVBIEL
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Controllers Policy
| > | Policy: SystemEnvironmentPrivilege
| > | Computer Setting: Administrators
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Controllers Policy
| > | Policy: IncreaseQuotaPrivilege
| > | Computer Setting: Administrators
| > | NETWORK SERVICE
| > | LOCAL SERVICE
| > | STADTBIEL\IWAM_GHOSTSRVBIEL
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Controllers Policy
| > | Policy: BatchLogonRight
| > | Computer Setting: STADTBIEL\SQLDebugger
| > | STADTBIEL\IIS_WPG
| > | STADTBIEL\IUSR_GHOSTSRVBIEL
| > | STADTBIEL\SUPPORT_388945a0
| > | LOCAL SERVICE
| > | STADTBIEL\IWAM_GHOSTSRVBIEL
| > | STADTBIEL\Administrator
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Controllers Policy
| > | Policy: DenyInteractiveLogonRight
| > | Computer Setting: STADTBIEL\SQLDebugger
| > | STADTBIEL\SUPPORT_388945a0
| > |
| > | Security Options
| > | ----------------
| > | GPO: Default Domain Policy
| > | Policy: TicketValidateClient
| > | Computer Setting: Enabled
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Policy
| > | Policy: RequireLogonToChangePassword
| > | Computer Setting: Not Enabled
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Policy
| > | Policy: PasswordComplexity
| > | Computer Setting: Not Enabled
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Policy
| > | Policy: ForceLogoffWhenHourExpire
| > | Computer Setting: Not Enabled
| > |
| > | GPO: Default Domain Policy
| > | Policy: ClearTextPassword
| > | Computer Setting: Not Enabled
| > |
| > | Event Log Settings
| > | ------------------
| > | N/A
| > |
| > | Restricted Groups
| > | -----------------
| > | N/A
| > |
| > | System Services
| > | ---------------
| > | N/A
| > |
| > | Registry Settings
| > | -----------------
| > | N/A
| > |
| > | File System Settings
| > | --------------------
| > | N/A
| > |
| > | Public Key Policies
| > | -------------------
| > | N/A
| > |
| > | Administrative Templates
| > | ------------------------
| > | N/A
| > |
| > |
| > | USER SETTINGS
| > | --------------
| > | CN=Administrator,CN=Users,DC=stadtbiel,DC=local
| > | Last time Group Policy was applied: 20.07.2005 at 13:12:47
| > | Group Policy was applied from: ghostsrvbiel.stadtbiel.local
| > | Group Policy slow link threshold: 500 kbps
| > | Domain Name: STADTBIEL
| > | Domain Type: Windows 2000
| > |
| > | Applied Group Policy Objects
| > | -----------------------------
| > | Default Domain Policy
| > |
| > | The following GPOs were not applied because they were filtered out
| > |
-------------------------------------------------------------------
| > | 1stSW
| > | Filtering: Not Applied (Empty)
| > |
| > | Local Group Policy
| > | Filtering: Not Applied (Empty)
| > |
| > | The user is a part of the following security groups
| > | ---------------------------------------------------
| > | Domain Users
| > | Everyone
| > | BUILTIN\Administrators
| > | BUILTIN\Users
| > | BUILTIN\Pre-Windows 2000 Compatible Access
| > | NT AUTHORITY\INTERACTIVE
| > | NT AUTHORITY\Authenticated Users
| > | This Organization
| > | LOCAL
| > | Domain Admins
| > | Group Policy Creator Owners
| > | Exchange Services
| > | Exchange Domain Servers
| > | Schema Admins
| > | Enterprise Admins
| > | Exchange Enterprise Servers
| > |
| > | The user has the following security privileges
| > | ----------------------------------------------
| > |
| > | Bypass traverse checking
| > | Manage auditing and security log
| > | Back up files and directories
| > | Restore files and directories
| > | Change the system time
| > | Shut down the system
| > | Force shutdown from a remote system
| > | Take ownership of files or other objects
| > | Debug programs
| > | Modify firmware environment values
| > | Profile system performance
| > | Profile single process
| > | Increase scheduling priority
| > | Load and unload device drivers
| > | Create a pagefile
| > | Adjust memory quotas for a process
| > | Remove computer from docking station
| > | Perform volume maintenance tasks
| > | Impersonate a client after authentication
| > | Create global objects
| > | Enable computer and user accounts to be trusted for delegation
| > | Add workstations to domain
| > |
| > | Resultant Set Of Policies for User
| > | -----------------------------------
| > |
| > | Software Installations
| > | ----------------------
| > | N/A
| > |
| > | Logon Scripts
| > | -------------
| > | N/A
| > |
| > | Logoff Scripts
| > | --------------
| > | N/A
| > |
| > | Public Key Policies
| > | -------------------
| > | N/A
| > |
| > | Administrative Templates
| > | ------------------------
| > | N/A
| > |
| > | Folder Redirection
| > | ------------------
| > | N/A
| > |
| > | Internet Explorer Browser User Interface
| > | ----------------------------------------
| > | N/A
| > |
| > | Internet Explorer Connection
| > | ----------------------------
| > | N/A
| > |
| > | Internet Explorer URLs
| > | ----------------------
| > | N/A
| > |
| > | Internet Explorer Security
| > | --------------------------
| > | N/A
| > |
| > | Internet Explorer Programs
| > | --------------------------
| > | N/A
| > |
| > |
| > |
| >
|
|
|

.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: GPO Update Problem (SYSVOL access via UNC)
    ... Server Security and Auditing Policy ... This list only includes links in the domain of the GPO. ... The settings in this GPO can only apply to the following groups, users, ...
    (microsoft.public.win2000.group_policy)
  • Re: GPO Update Problem (SYSVOL access via UNC)
    ... > Server Security and Auditing Policy ... > This list only includes links in the domain of the GPO. ... > The settings in this GPO can only apply to the following groups, users, ...
    (microsoft.public.win2000.group_policy)
  • Re: GPO security settings not applied
    ... Domain Security Policy to set this. ... you can indeed set a password policy at the OU - level! ... >> Domain - Default Domain GPO ... User settings in the IT GPO (ex. ...
    (microsoft.public.win2000.group_policy)
  • Re: security template file import
    ... gpttmpl.inf in the secedit folder of the GPO file system folder ... > in here is a single file - GPTTMPL.INF that lists the securtiy settings ... > as i can see is a copy of an imported security settings file) - is this ... >> template outside of the GPO which you edit to contain all the security ...
    (microsoft.public.win2000.security)
  • Re: GPO Filtering
    ... It looks like you've got the SUS GPO linked to the OU in which the users ... Because the SUS settings are ... Group Policy slow link threshold: ... Applied Group Policy Objects ...
    (microsoft.public.windows.group_policy)