Re: HELP! Really strange problem w/AD and LDAP/LDIFDE
- From: ohaya <ohaya@xxxxxxx>
- Date: Tue, 23 Jan 2007 22:32:30 -0500
Joe,
FYI, I've just sent off an email with my "analysis" of what may be going on in this one, particular environment. Basically, I'm theorizing that there are two factors at work here:
1) Having the two AD machines with exactly the same Windows domain name (but different hostnames, and different IP addresses), and
2) Some behavior which I/we haven't been able to identify with the way that AD handles simple LDAP binds, among the 3 different username formats.
I've suggested that they can either:
1) Leave things as-is, since my web app is now working, or
2) Re-configure things into a more "orthodox" configuration. In particular, I've suggested/recommended that they eliminate the "2nd AD", and let me point my web app at the "1st" ("real") AD/Domain controller, since this is how the other sites are configured.
I wasn't involved in the original decision to standup the "2nd AD", so I don't know exactly why they did that, but this particular site is suppose to be testbed-type site, so it's suppose to resemble the other sites as closely as possible anyway.
My guess is someone was overly risk-aversive and didn't want to have the web app affecting the "1st AD" (strange, since this web app is already in production at 3 other sites :)!)...
I'd still be interested if anyone has any insight into what is going on with the current, admittedly strange, configuration, in particular as to how and why this would interact with the format of the usernames used for the simple LDAP binds!!
Thanks again!
Jim
Joe Kaplan wrote:
I think you may be on to something here, as there may be some additional involvement with DNS and/or the GC in order to service the simple bind with UPN username and perhaps that is behaving weirdly in this environment due to something in its "checkered" past. :).
However, I'm clueless on this level of detail, so I'd want someone from MS (or a more useful MVP type :)) to step in and hopefully elaborate on what's going on under the hood.
Joe K.
- Follow-Ups:
- References:
- HELP! Really strange problem w/AD and LDAP/LDIFDE
- From: ohaya
- Re: HELP! Really strange problem w/AD and LDAP/LDIFDE
- From: ohaya
- Re: HELP! Really strange problem w/AD and LDAP/LDIFDE
- From: Joe Kaplan
- Re: HELP! Really strange problem w/AD and LDAP/LDIFDE
- From: ohaya
- Re: HELP! Really strange problem w/AD and LDAP/LDIFDE
- From: Joe Kaplan
- Re: HELP! Really strange problem w/AD and LDAP/LDIFDE
- From: ohaya
- Re: HELP! Really strange problem w/AD and LDAP/LDIFDE
- From: ohaya
- Re: HELP! Really strange problem w/AD and LDAP/LDIFDE
- From: Joe Kaplan
- HELP! Really strange problem w/AD and LDAP/LDIFDE
- Prev by Date: Re: HELP! Really strange problem w/AD and LDAP/LDIFDE
- Next by Date: active directory in win2003 : accessing users & computers
- Previous by thread: Re: HELP! Really strange problem w/AD and LDAP/LDIFDE
- Next by thread: Re: HELP! Really strange problem w/AD and LDAP/LDIFDE
- Index(es):
Relevant Pages
|