Re: Is a DC needed Here?

Hello Ace,
Thank you for your time very much appreciated :)

1. My mail server does not require AD
2. Yes I have used both mail servers in the past to access the same
mailboxes and this worked very well. In order to do this you need a UNC for
the mailfolders and the ability for the mailsrver software to write to the
folders.Similar to IIS IUSER_Machine name (this mail server has webmail)
3.If I implement a file server and locate the mailboxes on the file server I
would need to write to those folders.And as you said his runs under a service.
4. I have also used NON MS software and accomplished this without a problem.


{One thing I cannot see how is to share mailbox info on both mailservers
because a mailbox is a difinitive object. If a client is accessing their
mailbox thru a specific server, it will not be able to check another server
without having a whole different account. WHen mail comes in, it goes to t
the users's mailbox on that particular server.}

This is not true in my case

I would see how you would think this if you were only trained on
exchange.However the purpose for this is to add redundency.
if the primary server is down the other server will still receive the mail
until the primary came back online. Hence no one misses thier mail.

This mail server does not act or work like exchange and I am very well read
on it.
My issue is how to get the permissions I needed on another machine without
adding AD DC to put it all together.

As I mentioned before I have already done this but it was on the other
server and not a third server unbiased if one was down.The mail still is
recieved.
Now I want to relocate the mailfolders and permit both servers to write to
the same mailboxes. But I am learning that I cannot do it unless I implement
a DC.

Which was the very first question in this post.
User accounts on each machine ia not going to help. Been there. Done that.
Thanks
Joe

"Ace Fekay [MVP]" wrote:

In news:9FA110C0-46A4-4F24-BDEF-07FF721B669C@xxxxxxxxxxxxx,
Joe <Joe@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> stated, which I commented on below:
Hello Paul
Thanks for your time,

I do not use exchange servers I use third party mailservers.
So this is what I wanted to do but I do not think you can do this in
windows without an AD DC as I am aware of. Please advise on file
server permissions if you can.

Joe,

You need to read up on the documentation for the 3rd party mail servers you
are using. Are they AD dependent? If not, there's no reason to have a DC or
an AD infrastructure, unless you want to have centralized user and group
administration. What Paul mentioned is to control user access thru local
accounts on that specific machine. You can create local accounts on each
machine, if you so desire to. If AD is needed for the mail server you are
using, then you would need to study and read up on how that specific mail
server YOU are using uses Active Directory. For us to answer such a question
is practically impossible for a couple reasons, one of which we don't know
what mail server you're using, and two, even if we knew, we would need to
read up on it.

Exchange REQUIRES AD, matter of fact the user mailbox accounts are created
by creating a user account in AD. Matter of fact, AD is the actual directory
service (for the user mailbox accounts) that Exchange uses to store the user
accounts. Exchange reads AD info concerning any accounts that has a mailbox
created for them. Does your mail server do that or do you have to create
mail users in that 3rd party mail server you are using?

Does your mail server require AD? (If not sure, read the docs for as I said,
we do not know that answer).

Do you presently have an AD infrastructure in place that your users are
using and logging into each day?

As for file permissions, file server permissions would not have anything to
do with mailboxe access, since mailboxes are not accessed thru the file
system itself but rather thru the mail server services, and this goes for no
matter what 3rd party mail server you are using. However, mailbox access
permissions do exist and they are set within the 3rd party mail server
properties in the mail server's user mailbox configuration. With Exchange,
it's done thru AD.

One thing I cannot see how is to share mailbox info on both mailservers
because a mailbox is a difinitive object. If a client is accessing their
mailbox thru a specific server, it will not be able to check another server
without having a whole different account. WHen mail comes in, it goes to t
the users's mailbox on that particular server.

As Paul stated, you cannot do that with Exchange and AD, nor can I see it
being done on any other 3rd party mail service, unless it's clustered, and
clustering ability will be dictated by the fact if the 3rd party mail server
you are using will support clustering.


--
Ace

This posting is provided "AS-IS" with no warranties or guarantees and
confers no rights.

Having difficulty reading or finding responses to your post?
Instead of the website you're using, I suggest to use OEx (Outlook Express
or any other newsreader), and configure a news account, pointing to
news.microsoft.com. This is a direct link to the Microsoft Public
Newsgroups. It is FREE and requires NO ISP's Usenet account. OEx allows you
to easily find, track threads, cross-post, sort by date, poster's name,
watched threads or subject.

It's easy:
How to Configure OEx for Internet News
http://support.microsoft.com/?id=171164

Ace Fekay, MCSE 2003 & 2000, MCSA 2003 & 2000, MCSE+I, MCT, MVP
Microsoft MVP - Directory Services
Microsoft Certified Trainer

Infinite Diversities in Infinite Combinations
Assimilation Imminent. Resistance is Futile
"Very funny Scotty. Now, beam down my clothes."

The only thing in life is change. Anything more is a blackhole consuming
unnecessary energy. - [Me]




.

Relevant Pages

  • The Esc Character.
    ... I then tried Mac help for the Mac email client that I use with effectivity to find the article I copy and paste below. ... where I selected all of the messages and then clicked on Remove From Server. ... My mailbox is over its quota ... For .Mac or IMAP accounts, click the Size header to find the largest mail folders on your server. ...
    (comp.sys.mac.misc)
  • Re: mailbox disabled
    ... When the user accounts on the server were initially created the client ... e-mail from outside the network would receive the "mailbox has been ... had been told the mailbox was disabled on the recipient ...
    (microsoft.public.exchange.admin)
  • Re: mailbox disabled
    ... POP3 provider was still being used as a backup. ... it was a server problem. ... just from the senders' servers stating that the mailbox was ... I stepped back today to see what the accounts that were working ...
    (microsoft.public.exchange.admin)
  • Re: mailbox disabled
    ... Your POP3 connector question made me realize that the ... we got tunnel vision thinking it was a server problem. ... that the mailbox was disabled. ... I stepped back today to see what the accounts that were working seemed to ...
    (microsoft.public.exchange.admin)
  • Re: DoveCot vs Cyrus-Imapd Performance
    ... > I have a mail server that supports approximately 50-60 radio stations ... > certain number of users at the main office to use Webmin to add accounts ... > to the mail server. ... Alpha Server running Tru64 Unix (and later cluster of several Alpha ...
    (Fedora)
Quantcast