Remote Desktop Connection Only Works One Way

From: Andre (iam_at_daslimpoet.com)
Date: 05/29/04


Date: Sat, 29 May 2004 02:35:16 -0700

I just had (and resolved) the same problem yesterday.
After three days of wondering, testing, and question
asking to all the right (and sometimes wrong) network
administrators in various GOVERNMENT agencies, I hit
paydirt.

I have two home towers. Both have XP Pro. Computer(A) is
connected via Verizon Online DSL. Computer(B) was
connected via NetZero dial-up (for testing purposes). (A)
could RDC (B) but not vice-versa.

The IP Address that NetZero assigned (B) was a legitimate
(public) IP Address (although short-lived because NetZero
will timeout rather quickly if system remains idle, thus
requiring you to restart the NetZero connection and be
assigned a new temporary IP Address).

The IP Address that was assigned to (A) was from a private
series (192.168.*.*) of IP addresses set by a DHCP through
my DSL modem. (i.e. - my modem also acts as a kind of
router). What does that mean? That means my (real)
public IP Address was being hidden for some ungodly
reason. I went to my command prompt and
typed "ipconfig". I found out my default gateway and
typed it in the address bar on Internet Explorer
(http://192.168.*.*). This gave me a login prompt to
input the username and password I initially used to
activate my modem & DSL service allowing me access to all
kinds of system and configuration info from Westell (my
modem manufacturer). I found out their DNS info and got
them to assign my modem a single (public) static IP
Address. I then manually assigned the new static IP
Address and DNS info to my computer versus allowing it to
automatically obtain both. And voila!!! Problem solved.
I can either activate ICF and be sure to allow remote
desktop traffic, or I can choose to not activate ICF and
flow smoothly either way.

Now, there is no guarantee that you will be able to take
the same steps to obtain a legitimate IP. But if your IP
Address starts with 192.168.*.*, you definitely need to
change it in order to remotely access your computer. You
may have to contact your ISP and find out from them what
your true IP Address is and manually reconfigure your
system.

Good luck... Hope this was helpful.

>-----Original Message-----
>Hi All,
>
>I'm trying to setup my home desktop to accept incoming
>remote desktop connections. My intent is to connect to my
>desktop from my laptop when I'm away from home. However, I
>can't get it to work. Here's the problem, everytime I try
>to connect to my desktop from the laptop I get the error
>message that, "The client could not connect to the remote
>computer. Remote connections might not be enabled...." The
>strange part is, I can connect to my laptop from my
desktop
>just fine. The settings are the same for both computers.
>I'm running XP Pro on both systems. I turned off the
>firewall for testing purposes. As a matter of fact, the
>only difference between the two systems is the way I'm
>connecting to the interenet. The desktop is using a
>broadband connection (Bellsouth DSL), and the laptop is
>using a dialup connection (Bellsouth Dialup). Does anybody
>have a clue why the Remote Desktop Connection is working
in
>one direction but not the other even though all the
>settings are the same for both computers? BTW I also tried
>to connect to a friend in England who is using a broadband
>connection, a cable modem setup. It didn't work in either
>direction either. Is there special settings for broadband
>connections or something? If anybody can provide some
help,
>I'd appreciate it.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: 1 way remote desktop
    ... I am using the local ip of the desktop as seen on my lan ... laptop = 192.168.0.3 ... also remote access connection mgr is up. ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.work_remotely)
  • Re: Switching OSs from Windows ME to Windows XP Home Edition SP2
    ... like to upgrade this laptop to use Win XP Home Edition SP2. ... Purchase an XP Home Upgrade CD at retail, ... DELETED the installed modem from the laptop (a U.S. ... Do you have a hispeed connection available? ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.help_and_support)
  • Re: Questions on controlling Home PC remotely - i.e. security and performance
    ... I'm about to go away for two weeks and will be taking my laptop. ... 1.Windows XP - Remote Desktop ... network. ... the laptop, say for checking and sending email, which internet connection ...
    (sci.med.transcription)
  • Re: Questions on controlling Home PC remotely - i.e. security and performance
    ... 1.Windows XP - Remote Desktop ... two home PCs that are networked as well as XP Home on my laptop. ... network. ... the laptop, say for checking and sending email, which internet connection ...
    (sci.med.transcription)
  • Re: Remote Web Workplace Issue
    ... So, if you don't use the Air Card, youu can connect to the remote ... the laptop is not connected to the domain at the moment). ... This appears to be a workstation issue. ... The trouble laptop can successfully make a connection to the SBS ...
    (microsoft.public.windows.server.sbs)