WinXP firewall on which ICS computer(s)?

From: Old Geezer (nowhere_at_all.net)
Date: 07/26/04


Date: Mon, 26 Jul 2004 16:33:40 -0400

I am building a new computer with Windows XP Home Edition, which I am going
to use as the gateway machine for my DSL service when I set up Internet
Connection Sharing. Two or three other computers (WinXP and WinME) will
occasionally use the Internet through this gateway computer.

I bought a copy of "Windows XP Home Edition: The Missing Manual," which
seems like a worthwhile book though it has at least a couple of errors, I
think. But here's something that has me stumped:

On the subject of WinXP's Internet firewall, on p. 299 it says "if you've
set up several PCs to share one Internet connection, turn on the XP firewall
option only for the *first* computer--the one that's connected directly to
the Internet. Otherwise, the firewall software will prevent your *own*
computers from talking to each other."

But on p. 492 it says "the Personal Firewall feature should be turned on for
all computers *except* the gateway computer."

Which of these contradictory instructions (if either) is correct? Any
clarification will be much appreciated.



Relevant Pages

  • WinXP firewall on which ICS computer(s)?
    ... I am building a new computer with Windows XP Home Edition, ... to use as the gateway machine for my DSL service when I set up Internet ... On the subject of WinXP's Internet firewall, on p. 299 it says "if you've ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.general)
  • RE: Firewall / Internet Gateway Config Fails
    ... Firewall / Internet Gateway Config Fails ... all the machines on the lan are already configured to ...
    (RedHat)
  • Re: Suggest firewall for Win98se+ICS(dialup)+NAV
    ... > gateway for a peer-to-peer LAN with two workstations behind it? ... > use some sort of software firewall, e.g., SPF, as a network gateway ... > server, mail server, news server, or FTP server running on the Win 98 SE ... handles inbound from the internet and outbound from the gateway box. ...
    (comp.security.firewalls)
  • Re: Backup paths to the internet.
    ... the primary path to the Internet is through eth0 the first ... However if that gateway is down, ... This a standalone distribution and very small. ... The firewall software is shorewall and it is a real hardware firewall ...
    (Ubuntu)
  • Re: avast
    ... > Just did a clean installation of xp pro sp1 and download 'avast anti ... Did you firewall before connecting to the internet? ... Internet and patch with the critical updates? ... Why you should use a computer firewall.. ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.general)