Re: Is It Even Worth It To Install SP2???

From: Jupiter Jones [MVP] (jones_jupiter_at_hotnomail.com)
Date: 09/01/04


Date: Wed, 1 Sep 2004 12:36:53 -0600

Going slow is not always bad.
But the user must research possible problems in advance and be ready
for them.
It is extremely unlikely another version of SP-2 would be released to
resolve perceived or actual issues so what would be a problem today
would also be a problem in 6 months if the user does nothing in that
time.

-- 
Jupiter Jones  [MVP]
http://www3.telus.net/dandemar/
"MAP" <MAP@discussions.microsoft.com> wrote in message 
news:A3FD9C0C-0C5F-4EF0-B927-C54A9708B91F@microsoft.com...
> I agree with Rich.
> Here are what some NON-Microsoft experts are saying about SP2
>
> ) Go Slow With XP's SP2
> Many readers are wondering what to do about XP's SP2, which is 
> starting to
> trickle out in a limited release. But over the next few weeks, just 
> about all
> XP users will be offered the download in a carefully sequenced 
> rollout
> designed to prevent the overload of Microsoft's servers.
>
> When you're offered SP2, my advice is: Do nothing; wait a bit.
>
> SP2 is huge--- so big it's almost a whole new version of XP. Like 
> any new
> version of any OS, it *will* contain bugs, and it *will* cause 
> trouble on
> some setups. The more complex and/or nonstandard your setup is, the 
> greater
> the likelihood of a problem.
>
> Plus, there's no "must have right now" element to SP2: Much of SP2 
> is
> designed to force uninformed (or just plain lazy!) PC users to use 
> basic
> security--- to stay current with updates, to use a firewall, etc. 
> (These are
> the users running the unpatched/unprotected systems that allow most
> worms/viruses to spread.)
>
> But odds are, if you're reading this newsletter, you already know 
> about and
> are using pretty good security practices, such as good firewall, 
> antivirus
> and anti-spyware tools, and you're keeping up to date with Critical 
> Updates.
> If that's the case, you won't gain a lot by rushing into SP2.
>
> Instead, wait a bit--- even as much as a month or two--- to let the 
> worst
> problems with SP2 come to light and be fixed on other user's PCs.
>
> Again, as long as you're already using the kinds of security tools 
> and
> techniques we discuss in this newsletter every week (example:
> http://www.informationweek.com/840/langa.htm ), there's no need to 
> rush into
> SP2.
>
> I'm not the only one suggesting this "go slow" approach. See, for 
> example
> these other authors:
> http://www.scotsnewsletter.com/60.htm
> http://channelzone.ziffdavis.com/article2/0,1759,1633858,00.asp
>
> But if you absolutely must try it as soon as you can, MAKE A FULL 
> IMAGE
> BACKUP OF YOUR SYSTEM! (There, I hope that got your attention! <g>) 
> You can
> use a free trial version of BootIt for example (
> http://www.terabyteunlimited.com/ ), and have a bulletproof way to 
> roll your
> system back to pre-SP2 condition if things don't work out. Note that 
> standard
> uninstall, backup or roll-back tools (like Go Back) may NOT suffice 
> for an
> update of this size and scope. If you want to be 100% sure you can 
> undo SP2
> in its totality, you *must* use a heavy-duty imaging tool. See
> http://search.atomz.com/search/?sp-q=imaging&sp-a=0008002a-sp00000000 .
>
> But for most of us, the answer's simpler: Relax! Take a break, and 
> let
> others blaze a trail for you!  Eventually, SP2 will be worth 
> installing, but
> for most of us--- almost everyone--- there's no particular need for, 
> or
> benefit from, being an early adopter
> 


Relevant Pages

  • Re: Do i need SP2?
    ... > I am running XP pro with all updates EXCEPT SP2. ... many patches will begin requiring SP2 to install.. ... and some you can only download if you are registered - but it is best ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.general)
  • Re: msconfig missing not a virus
    ... It is a file backup not an image backup. ... > sp2 with all associated critical updates available to download. ... created the slipstream windows disk and ran system>> file ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.general)
  • Re: All who think SP2 is SOOOO great,
    ... SP2 is a great upgrade. ... >is enough to make a backup. ... >and install updates enabled. ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.general)
  • Re: New install of winxp home.....
    ... Download the SP2 and all subsequent patches on another already secured ... Turn on "Automatic Updates" and create the following registry key to be ... If you are going to use Internet Explorer and Outlook Express: ...
    (microsoft.public.security)
  • Re: All who think SP2 is SOOOO great,
    ... SP2 is a great upgrade. ... is enough to make a backup. ... I think automatic updates is as good as making a large download ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.general)