Re: Hey FAT32 users, take advantage of new exFAT file system



Thee Chicago Wolf wrote:
Yes, I don't see why not. It appears to be backwards compatible. Of
course, if you should ever plug an exFAT formatted drive into another
XP computer without the exFAT driver, you'd be hosed. In reality,
you'd be better off converting your FAT32 to NTFS using the convert
command so you won't have to worry about any limitations of the FAT32
or exFAT filesystems. You'd also be better protected against data
corruption. If it's just a storage drive, you shouldn't encounter any
permission issues since it just a storage volume and not your C:
drive.

Seconded. The article was is interesting, but there are too many
potential pitfalls with using it, as you've mentioned.

Maybe, maybe not. It just seems that when FAt32 was introduced way
back in 1996, MS must not have realized that 10+ years later we'd be
dealing with files that were 4GB or bigger and hit the FAT32 ceiling.
It's nice that at least it's getting an update. Even if it it's a bit
post mortem. Still, the FAT32 folks will appreciate it until the rest
of the planet starts getting devices formatted exFAt

It's not going to happen. Anyone dealing with large files (> 4GB) is
already using NTFS (for the partition containing such files), and this
avoids the legacy problems introduced by introducing such a new format that
is not backwards compatible. In short, there is little value to it.

Even if your main C: boot drive is currently using FAT32, you have a couple
of other more sound choices:

1) convert that partition to NTFS (but make a backup first, of course), and
join the rest of the XP world. :-) NTFS has some obvious advantages
here.
I'm not sure how problematic the conversion can be for a boot drive, though.
(better yet, do a fresh install of XP on NTFS, and then reinstall your apps)

OR

2) use another partition formatted as NTFS to store and work with such large
files, say like a partition named "Video". (which I think is principally
where you need to work with such large files)


.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: When did large external hard drives come formatted with NTFS?
    ... drives come pre-formatted as NTFS. ... removable flash memory media formatted as FAT32, ... Partition Magic pay royalties to MS because they can format out NTFS? ...
    (alt.comp.hardware.pc-homebuilt)
  • Re: Copying problem with Gigabyte files
    ... storage capacity und repeat procedure. ... Change/format the external drive with NTFS instead of the FAT32 it ... That would be NTFS ... As I said - change or format the external drive with NTFS instead of FAT32 ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.help_and_support)
  • Re: Large msdosfs disk will not mount on RELENG_6
    ... I am very suprised at all that windows would allow you to format a 500G drive into a single 500G FAT32 partition. ... Any bigger and it will force you to use NTFS. ... I bought one last week as well, and tried to mount it to extract the included software before repartitioning. ...
    (freebsd-stable)
  • Re: format usb drive to fat 32
    ... had been formatted to NTFS previously. ... Format larger than 32GB FAT32 within Windows XP with this utility: ... "FAT32 supports drives up to 2 terabytes in size." ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.general)
  • Re: Returning drive to fat32 from NTFS
    ... I notice it is NTFS while my other drive and partiotions on it are Fat32. ... Detailed steps please or is it as simple as typing format E: How do I designate Fat32 or will it ask me. ... Assuming your drive is> 32 GB, you could, of course, multi-partition it in the DM utility so that at least one partition you create is < 32 GB. ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.general)