Re: "Convert" NTFS to FAT32 after Saving HDD Contents

Anna wrote:
On Thu, 27 Mar 2008 11:43:44 GMT, bpetria@xxxxxxxxxxx (Brad) wrote:

Hi,

Is it possible to save WinXP HDD (NTFS) contents such as "WINDOWS",
"Program Files", "Documents and Settings", (etc.) folder "trees",
format
the
HDD as FAT32, then transfer saved contents back to HDD without causing
problems?


"Ken Blake, MVP" <kblake@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:aa0ou3lbct7migdj4vitq8hgdqf2bddcu5@xxxxxxxxxx
Sure. The easiest way would be to clone the entire drive to a second
drive using a program like Acronis True Image, then clone it back
after reformatting the original drive.

However, it's probably simpler to just convert the drive from NTFS to
FAT32, using one the several third-party programs with this
capability.

Why do you want to do this? Except for those dual booting to an
operating system that isn't NTFS-aware, NTFS is the better choice.

--
Ken Blake, Microsoft MVP - Windows Desktop Experience
Please Reply to the Newsgroup


Anna wrote:
Ken & bpetria:
Actually that wouldn't work. Even if the user reformatted his/her HDD
FAT32 after cloning the contents to another disk, the re:cloning process
would
just carry over the file system on the cloned contents - in this case
NTFS. So the user would be right back where he/she started from.

As you & others have indicated if, for some reason, the user *must* have
a
FAT32 file system, the conversion process should be undertaken using a
third-party program such as Partition Magic. (Nearly) needless to say, a
clone of the original contents of the HDD should most definitely be
created *prior* to the conversion process. (The relatively few times
we've
undertaken this kind of conversion using PM we experienced no problems.
But unquestionably the potential for loss or corrupted data is surely
present).
Anna


"Bill in Co." <not_really_here@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:OdVBgNFkIHA.4244@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Right. If it's just a partition copy, it partition copies the source
drive as it is.

Yup, PM would be the way to go. But I'm curious here. What reason
did you do this, Anna? Because the user wanted to be able to see and
access his drive from Win9x in a dual boot situation, or??


Bill:
We tried it some number of times just for testing purposes.

There were, however, a few times (probably no more than 3 or 4 in my
experience as I recall) when a user (in this case some small-to-medium
sized
businesses) were in the process of converting their systems from Win98 to
WinXP not too long after XP was released. We ran into some problems
involving corruption or loss of data with certain of their custom-designed
programs that they were using. These programs had been designed during the
Win9x era and hadn't been updated for XP, the designers of these programs
having long departed the scene.

Yup. Sounds familiar. :-)

As a last resort we converted the XP NTFS
file system back to FAT32. Lo & behold the problems they formerly
encountered disappeared. Why this should happen was (and is) a mystery. I
haven't kept in touch but no doubt these organizations have most likely
updated their systems & programs so I would guess they're no longer using
the FAT32 file system in an XP environment.
Anna

It's interesting that those few programs would work, once you went back to
FAT32. It appears simply that their file reads and writes weren't able to
cope with (or even recognize) NTFS, and maybe that's all there was to it.
I wonder which programs they were. Perhaps some older disk utility
programs.

I've brought most of my older Win98 programs over to WinXP, and most all of
them made the trip ok, but I can't recall which few didn't at the moment.
(Probably some older disk utility programs).


.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Sorry to have to ask this.
    ... The file system on a CD is CDFS which can be read by other OS'es.. ... MVP - Windows Shell/User ... >>> dilemma of whether or not to go with NTFS or stick with FAT32. ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.general)
  • Re: NTFS vs FAT32
    ... > Meaning my XP is running in NTFS, but my data is saved in FAT32 Disk D. ... to be less severe than on a FAT32 file system. ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.basics)
  • Re: "Convert" NTFS to FAT32 after Saving HDD Contents
    ... HDD as FAT32, then transfer saved contents back to HDD without causing ... it's probably simpler to just convert the drive from NTFS to ... just carry over the file system on the cloned contents - in this case ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.general)
  • Re: Sorry to have to ask this.
    ... And now I'm faced with the old dilemma of whether or not to go with NTFS or stick with FAT32. ... Limitations of the FAT32 File System in Windows XP ... Instead, because WinXP is descended from the WinNT/2K OS family, it has a command line utility called "Chkdsk," which performs much better. ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.general)
  • Re: OT - Desktop Linux
    ... obvious presence in the file system). ... system services executables. ... If you have Linux or other OS, almost all of them can mount NTFS shares. ... or functionality and I don't think FAT32 is going to be unstable vs NTFS, ...
    (alt.sports.basketball.nba.la-lakers)
Loading