Re: A Can Ping B, But B Cannot Ping A?



Per over@xxxxxxxx:
The little voice is possibly correct.
Do you have file and printer sharing enabled as a firewall exception on B
but not on A? The firewall lets everything out, but only certain things
in, so this would allow A to access B, but not the other way around.
Allowing ping in appears to be tied to file sharing - if I turn this
exception off and on, it also blocks or allows ping.

If you mean Windows Firewall|Exceptions|File and Printer Sharing = Checked, then
yes - both PCs have it checked.

I'm starting to wonder, however, if it's a Windows Firewall issue bc when I turn
Windows Firewall off on both PCs (Windows Firewall|Off (not recommended) =
Checked) the problem persists.

OTOH, with both firewalls off, machine B can open up the workgroup and see
machine A.... although when it tries to open A, it throws "\\Asus is not
accessible.... You may not have permission.... The network path was not found."
in spite of A's having things in it's "Shared Documents" folder.

OTOOH, the goofey thing where A opens B's SharedDocs and sees itself persists...
--
PeteCresswell
.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Cant find out why I cant access printer on xp home machine
    ... I have "file and printer sharing" as an exception allowed in the ... "Windows cannot connect to the printer. ... I have even disabled the firewall on the xp home computer, ... If you don't find a problem in Windows Networking, check the file sharing setup ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.network_web)
  • Re: File and Printer Sharing bug with Norton Personal Firewall 2004
    ... > There is definitely 100% a File and Printer Sharing bug with Norton ... > I have File and Printer Sharing Configured with maximum permissiveness. ... > firewall off and on again, on both computers, it works. ... > ANY SETTINGS OR DO ANYTHING JUST SHUT ALL WINDOWS. ...
    (comp.security.firewalls)
  • Re: Cannot share Printer on Network
    ... Computer Name tab you will see the name of the workgroup. ... Windows Firewall, on the exceptions tab be sure that the files and printer ... running Win XP Home Edition and 2 notebooks connected ... I set up Printer sharing following instructions form Microsoft's site ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.hardware)
  • Re: Cannot share Printer on Network
    ... If you right click My Computer and select properties then select the Computer Name tab you will see ... In the filewall you need to make sure file and printer sharing are allowed to pass through the ... In the control panel select the Windows Firewall, on the exceptions tab be sure that the ... However, when I went to my notebook and clicked Add a New Printer, I didnt see the HP printer's ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.hardware)
  • Re: Black Ice and smb
    ... I assumed that your router had a firewall and I assumed wrongly. ... So if you have turned on the option Internet Sharing with BlackIce turn it ... because your machines using MS File and Printer Sharing bound to the ...
    (comp.security.firewalls)