Re: GroupBy Error
From: Joe Celko (jcelko212_at_earthlink.net)
Date: 11/16/04
- Next message: J. Joshi: "Maintaining Field Length in .txt format"
- Previous message: David C: "Update one table from another"
- In reply to: SusieQ: "GroupBy Error"
- Next in thread: SusieQ: "Re: GroupBy Error"
- Reply: SusieQ: "Re: GroupBy Error"
- Messages sorted by: [ date ] [ thread ]
Date: Tue, 16 Nov 2004 14:30:31 -0800
1) All of your data element names are in violation of ISO-11179 naming
rules. The "tbl-" prefix, names like "type_id", "category_id", etc. are
textbook examples of how not to write SQL.
2) You do not understand how a SELECT statement works. Here is how a
SELECT works in SQL ... at least in theory. Real products will optimize
things when they can.
a) Start in the FROM clause and build a working table from all of the
joins, unions, intersections, and whatever other table constructors are
there. The table expression> AS <correlation name> option allows you
give a name to this working table which you then have to use for the
rest of the containing query.
b) Go to the WHERE clause and remove rows that do not pass criteria;
that is, that do not test to TRUE (reject UNKNOWN and FALSE). The WHERE
clause is applied to the working set in the FROM clause.
c) Go to the optional GROUP BY clause, make groups and reduce each
group to a single row, replacing the original working table with the new
grouped table. The rows of a grouped table must be group
characteristics: (1) a grouping column (2) a statistic about the group
(i.e. aggregate functions) (3) a function or (4) an expression made up
those three items.
d) Go to the optional HAVING clause and apply it against the grouped
working table; if there was no GROUP BY clause, treat the entire table
as one group.
e) Go to the SELECT clause and construct the expressions in the list.
This means that the scalar subqueries, function calls and expressions in
the SELECT are done after all the other clauses are done. The “AS”
operator can also give names to expressions in the SELECT list. These
new names come into existence all at once, but after the WHERE clause,
GROUP BY clause and HAVING clause has been executed; you cannot use them
in the SELECT list or the WHERE clause for that reason.
If there is a SELECT DISTINCT, then redundant duplicate rows are
removed. For purposes of defining a duplicate row, NULLs are treated as
matching (just like in the GROUP BY).
f) Nested query expressions follow the usual scoping rules you would
expect from a block structured language like C, Pascal, Algol, etc.
Namely, the innermost queries can reference columns and tables in the
queries in which they are contained.
g) The ORDER BY clause is part of a cursor, not a query. The result set
is passed to the cursor, which can only see the names in the SELECT
clause list, and the sorting is done there. The ORDER BY clause cannot
have expression in it, or references to other columns because the result
set has been converted into a sequential file structure and that is what
is being sorted.
As you can see, things happen "all at once" in SQL, not from left to
right as they would in a sequential file/proceudral language model. In
those languages, these two statements produce different results:
READ (a, b, c) FROM File_X;
READ (c, a, b) FROM File_X;
while these two statements return the same data:
SELECT a, b, c FROM Table_X;
SELECT c, a, b FROM Table_X;
Think about what a confused mess this statement is in the SQL model.
SELECT f(c2) AS c1, f(c1) AS c2 FROM Foobar;
That is why such nonsense is illegal syntax.
--CELKO--
Please post DDL, so that people do not have to guess what the keys,
constraints, Declarative Referential Integrity, datatypes, etc. in your
schema are. Sample data is also a good idea, along with clear
specifications.
*** Sent via Developersdex http://www.developersdex.com ***
Don't just participate in USENET...get rewarded for it!
- Next message: J. Joshi: "Maintaining Field Length in .txt format"
- Previous message: David C: "Update one table from another"
- In reply to: SusieQ: "GroupBy Error"
- Next in thread: SusieQ: "Re: GroupBy Error"
- Reply: SusieQ: "Re: GroupBy Error"
- Messages sorted by: [ date ] [ thread ]
Relevant Pages
|
