Collation and Win2K3 Clustered Environment.

From: MikeH (MikeH_at_discussions.microsoft.com)
Date: 02/16/05


Date: Wed, 16 Feb 2005 06:39:08 -0800

This past weekend I was challenged a little in resolving what I hoped was a
simple collation issue. We are running Win2K3 Ent. Clustering Services, SQL
Server 2000 Enterprise, b.8.00.760.

On Friday, 2.11, a user migrated an application to this new clustered setup
and immediately received the infamous 446 collation error.

I spent most of Friday evening and all day Saturday reviewing support topics
and news groups. I found that there was 1 issue that could be affecting us -
the build of SQL Server for Win2K3 Ent. Clustering is subtly different than
for Win2KAS Clustering - and all of my research came back to one thing: Run
rebuildm.exe and set the collation of this instance to be the same as the
existing development/production environment. The default setup on the cluster
was different than the previous production setup, as well as different than
the current development environment.

So, I backed everyone's database up, then the master objects, shut the
instance down, executed rebuild and set the collation to what I needed it to
be.

When I brought this user's database online - the same exact error occurs.

Prior to doing this, here is what we were faced with:
Development / Previous Production: Server=Win2K, SQL=SQL Server 2000
Enterprise w/Collate=SQL_Latin1_General_CP1_CI_AS.

The new clustered SQL=SQL Server Enterprise, w/Collate=Latin1_General_CI_AI.

The database/application in question, at the procedure where we receive the
collation error, basically calls a function that creates a temp table, then
another that pulls data for a report - however, the data is collected as a
JOIN on this tempdb temp object and a series of Views the programmer
previously setup. These views in turn hit various other static tables as well.

We were thinking that because of the collation difference on the new Win2K3
setup, as well as Collation/Locale settings differences with Win2K3
Clustering, we should at a minimum change the instance to match the
SQL_Latin1, etc. collation of development. This however, has not solved the
problem.

At this juncture, the Win2K3 Clustered server has the collation
SQL_Latin1_General_CP1_CI_AI, and the development environment (as well as
their current production environment, which is 2KAS nonclustered) is
SQL_Latin1_General_CP1_CI_AS... The only difference in the two right now is
the accent sensitivity - but this should not be the issue.

If anyone else out there has any feedback, I'd be grateful for your time.

Thanks....

mhamilton"AT"nusoftsolutions"DOT"com



Relevant Pages

  • RE: Collation and Win2K3 Clustered Environment.
    ... Bart, thanks for getting back to me. ... moving from 2KAS Clustering to 2K3 Clustering is NOT fun. ... experienced the infamous 446 collation error. ... setup, please feel free to contact me. ...
    (microsoft.public.sqlserver.clustering)
  • RE: Collation and Win2K3 Clustered Environment.
    ... If the collation names are different you'll get the collation conflict ... Microsoft SQL Server Support ... Clustering Services, ... and the development environment (as well as ...
    (microsoft.public.sqlserver.clustering)
  • Re: How do I change the default collation string of an installation
    ... different collation name in order to be able to accept the character set ... the DTSs successfully copy the Hebrew letters when I copy data with OSQL ... refers to specific databases and uses the destination database's ... OSQL refers to the remote server and destination server ...
    (comp.databases.ms-sqlserver)
  • Re: Different Collation designator Settings
    ... You can have databases with different collations on SQL ... That wasn't possible on SQL Server 7. ... values in temporary tables while assuming that tempdb has the same collation ...
    (microsoft.public.sqlserver.connect)
  • Re: Different Collation designator Settings
    ... You can have databases with different collations on SQL ... That wasn't possible on SQL Server 7. ... values in temporary tables while assuming that tempdb has the same collation ...
    (microsoft.public.sqlserver.server)