Re: Late Dates incorrect after indenting under Summary Task

From: Sean (Sean_at_discussions.microsoft.com)
Date: 02/23/05 

Date: Wed, 23 Feb 2005 07:59:08 -0800

Let me explain better.

Create a project with the following info. The summary task is not Linked.
Don't indent it under the summary until you've added all the tasks. All
relationships are FS. Use a 5 day duration for all tasks. Insert the late
start field into your table.

Now, indent all the tasks under the sumary task. Watch the late dates
change. They shouldn't becuase there is no link or relationship to the
summary line. Microsoft has acknowledged the problem but has made no promise
to fix it. I've heard of some work around's but not found one that is 100%

Thanks
Sean

ID NAME PRED
1 summary
2 Start Milestone #1
3 Activity #1 2
4 Activity #2 3
5 Activity #3 4
6 Finish Milestone #1 5,10
7 Start Milestone #2
8 Activity #4 7
9 Activity #5 8
10 Activity #6 9
11 Start Milestone # 3
12 Activity #7 11
13 Activity #8 12
14 Activity #9 13
15 Finish Milestone #2 14

"Steve House [MVP]" wrote:

> I'm not aware of any "bug" like you're describing. The total slack time of
> a task is the amount of time it could be delayed without delaying the
> project finish, in a nutshell. Imagine Summary Task A with subtasks A1
> (3d), A2 (4d), & A3 (5d). The subtasks are not linked so they occur in
> parallel, all starting the same day. Summary task A links to Summary X FS
> and Summary X in turn links FS to the Finish milestone. What are the late
> dates of A1, A2, & A3? Summary A's finish is determined by A3 so the late
> date of A3 and Summary A are the same. Only if Summary A is delayed past
> that point will Summary X be delayed, hence that is also the latest date it
> can finish without delaying the project's finish. The late finishes of A1
> and A2 are also that same date as A3 (which is also the late finish of
> Summary A), since they could slip by 2 or 1 day respectively before they
> delay the finish of Summary A. I think that is what you're describing in
> your posting but where's the bug in that? That is exactly the way late
> starts and late finishes are supposed to be calculated and that's the way
> project does calculate them. And this is even with linking between the
> summary tasks, which is often considered a bad idea. The alternative
> linking would have A1, A2, and A3 all as predecessors to X1 and no links
> directly in or out of the summary tasks themselves but the results are
> exactly the same.
>
> If I'm missing something here, please give us some concrete example that
> demonstrates what you consider to be this bug - what Project gives you and
> what you think it should be giving you instead (and why you feel Project is
> wrong and your way is right). I'm really curious.
> --
> Steve House [MVP]
> MS Project Trainer & Consultant
> Visit http://www.mvps.org/project/faqs.htm for the FAQs
>
>
>
>
>
> "Sean" <Sean@discussions.microsoft.com> wrote in message
> news:8D16920B-D1B6-47F2-B279-B190C3F654F4@microsoft.com...
> > Many of you know there is a "bug" in MS Project that affects the late
> > dates
> > and backward pass.
> >
> > If you indent a group of tasks under the summary task the late dates for
> > that group are changed by the summary task. A weird problem that only
> > surfaces when calculating total slack and the backward pass.
> >
> > I've heard of some people using MSO/MFO anchors at the end of thier
> > network
> > to solve this. Does anybody else have a solution. My company (a rather
> > large one) has submitted this to Microsoft and they acknowledge that it is
> > a
> > bug, but aren't planning on fixing it anytime soon.
> >
> > Please advise.
> >
> > Sean
> >
>
>

Relevant Pages

  • Late Dates incorrect after indenting under Summary Task
    ... Many of you know there is a "bug" in MS Project that affects the late dates ... If you indent a group of tasks under the summary task the late dates for ... that group are changed by the summary task. ... surfaces when calculating total slack and the backward pass. ...
    (microsoft.public.project)
  • Re: Late Dates incorrect after indenting under Summary Task
    ... Forgot the critical part of constraints. ... > and indent everything under the summary task. ... >>>> can finish without delaying the project's finish. ...
    (microsoft.public.project)
  • Re: Help with MS Project Summary Tasks
    ... You don't have to create an overall project summary task. ... RightMouseButton on the toolbars and display the Formatting toolbar. ... Click on a task and click on the indent button to see ...
    (microsoft.public.project.pro_and_server)
  • Re: Milestones indentation
    ... You can get away with milestones being other than under the summary task, ... The reason of my post was because I remembered to see an advice somewhere to ... indent the milestones (the end milestone, nothing was mention about the start ...
    (microsoft.public.project)
  • Re: Phases question
    ... You insert the new summary task that represents the phase above the tasks ... that will be part of it and indent the *subtasks* (not the new task as you ... "Jack" wrote in message ...
    (microsoft.public.project)