Re: Using WMP to record voice?

From: Neil Smith [MVP Digital Media] (neil_at_nospam.com)
Date: 05/08/04


Date: Sat, 08 May 2004 14:37:59 +0100

On Fri, 7 May 2004 12:16:11 -0700, "andy"
<anonymous@discussions.microsoft.com> wrote:

>Neil,
>
> Thank you for your reply. When you say capture the audio uncompressed first, can I just use MS Sound Recorder?

Yes, although there are many 3rd party programs for doing this, sound
recorder is very old and has no features to speak of. I got creative
wave studio on my sound card drivers disk. Usually the sound card
manufacturer will include something similar for recording wav files.
Try to pre-process (equalize and limit / compress) using a mixing desk
before taking down to a stereo or mono stream.

Limiting means the peak level is limited to 100% of the range - eg
when somebody speaks too close to a mic, words beginning 'P' and 'S'
and so on are sometimes overloaded. Limiters make the pulse of audio
reach a maximum value. Probalbly not the best explanation in the world
- speak to your church's sound engineer types ;-)

> What tool or program would I use to edit (e.g. out the feedback, cough, volume level, etc.)?

I've used 'Soundforge' which is pretty good, can also add echo, remove
reverb and all sorts of other processing on the raw file. There are
loads of options, I'm sure people on here can suggest excellent free
sound file editors.

> You then suggest using Windows Media Encoder to encode and compress? Please expound. How, why, what tools?

Well you can use that or movie makes, but encoder gives tou more
options and control over the extent of compression. For example if
it's just speaking (no music etc) then you can compress real hard to
just the audio range used by speech - eg up to 8-10khz. The file is
usually then small enough to stream direct from a file on your website
to 56k modem users. An uncompressed audio track will be too large to
stream even over some DSL lines.

> If we record in MS sound recorder, it will be a .wav file, perhaps PCM, Radio Quality, 22.050 kHz, 8 bit mono, 21 kb/sec.

Sure you can. I'd sample at the highest rate - best quality - that you
have disk space for. Disks are cheap, going back to a file and trying
to improve quality after the event is difficult, expensive and usually
not successful. Try 44khz CD quality and work from there. 8bit sound
is usually cruddy anyway, really you need to use 16 bit for enough
levels (65000 vs 256) so it doesn't sound like a computer voice !

>Can't this be put directly onto a CD? or is this a bad idea?

Well, you'd be under-sampling. Just use the CD quality settings for
CD, then there's no mismatch between the capability of a CD's dynamic
range and that of the recording.

>Thank you again
>God bless you



Relevant Pages

  • Re: the cold hard facts about mp3 sound quality
    ... Apple has gone so far as to say that this results ?in audio ... So what exactly is a bitrate? ... that more sonic information can be used to recreate the sound. ... The degradation of CD quality into something even ...
    (rec.music.dylan)
  • the cold hard facts about mp3 sound quality
    ... To sweeten the deal, those tracks have better sound, with a bitrate of 256 kilobits per second (kbps), up from the standard 128 kbps. ... To careful listeners, or those with good audio equipment, more data can make a big difference. ... The degradation of CD quality into something even more limited is simply proof to many fervent music listeners that Armageddon is indeed at hand. ...
    (rec.music.dylan)
  • Re: Go Neil!
    ... quality of mp3 sampled at a 320 rate vs. the original ... as sound quality is more important than storage capacity. ... It'll just be a standard format 16 bit AIFF CD, and hopefully folks ... Neither Super Audio CD nor DVD Audio caught on and it seems like Super ...
    (rec.music.makers.guitar.acoustic)
  • Re: Budget Sound--is it even possible?
    ... any sort of quality), and am working on a budget of next to nothing--a ... need for a separate sound recorder in your case. ... microphone from Radio Shack mounted on a $20 telescoping lightbulb ...
    (rec.arts.movies.production.sound)
  • Re: No Sound Recorder
    ... Right - you don't need Sound Recorder for that. ... "To Test Sound Card Line-In Jack Using Audio Loopback: ... Go to the Control Panel and start the Sound and Audio Devices applet. ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.help_and_support)