Re: Template open/save behavior



It was done because the people who did it felt that this behaviour was "More
Mac-Like".

And as everyone here knows, am amongst those who say it's a bug :-)

The fact that they *intended* to create this behaviour does not alter the
fact that it is a bug :-)


On 11/2/06 1:06 PM, in article C012B0E5.D91F%onlygeneraltaz1@xxxxxxxxxxxx,
"CyberTaz" <onlygeneraltaz1@xxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

Although some might like to classify it as a 'bug', you can't as it was done
intentionally. It is actually a design change which I believe took place in
Office X (not sure 'cause I never used X very much). Why it was done I have
no idea.

Regards |:>)


On 2/10/06 8:12 PM, in article
1139620367.237718.321370@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx, "eae@xxxxxxxxxxxx"
<eae@xxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

It used to be that when Word opened a document classified as a
"template", no matter where it was, it would open it as a new dicument
named "Document n". You could not close it without saving it, and you
could not save it without giving it a name and location. That is,
"Save as" was the only available option.

With Word 2004, if you go to the "Project Gallery" and select a
template from there, it works exactly that way. However, if you go to
the finder, locate the template, or an alias of it, and double-click
that file, Word opens it, but not as an unnamed document, but as the
template itself. If you alter it then close it, you are asked if you
want to save it, and if you do, you save your changes in the template.
You are not forced to "Save as".

I tried changing the attibutes of a template to "Read only" which does
protect it, but you clearly see the difference - it's a document called
"template name (read only)" instead of "document n".

Am I missing something, or has Microsoft made a significant change in
template behavior, or is this a bug?



--

Please reply to the newsgroup to maintain the thread. Please do not email
me unless I ask you to.

John McGhie <john@xxxxxxxxxxx>
Microsoft MVP, Word and Word for Macintosh. Consultant Technical Writer
Sydney, Australia +61 (0) 4 1209 1410

.



Relevant Pages

  • New Bug: Word 2007: Can result in deletion of template files
    ... We're calling it the "Double Save Prompt" bug. ... It destroys template documents in a non-retrievable fashion. ... I went through the document and applied the new quickstyle sheets to the ...
    (microsoft.public.word.application.errors)
  • Re: VS 2005 Bug?
    ... I can confirm that this is an error in template argument deduction. ... I posted the bug on Microsoft Connect and just a few hour later the ... If you make the effort to report a bug, ...
    (microsoft.public.vc.language)
  • Re: New Bug: Word 2007: Can result in deletion of template files
    ... of a parent template), 3 are affected by this bug, and 1 is not. ... We're calling it the "Double Save Prompt" bug. ... I went through the document and applied the new quickstyle sheets to the ...
    (microsoft.public.word.application.errors)
  • Re: problem with non-existing templates
    ... Microsoft are far from perfect but this could hardly be called a bug! ... Have you tried my suggestion of putting a dummy template in the same ...
    (microsoft.public.word.vba.general)
  • Standard behaviour ?
    ... template ... Bar bar; ... than the standard ... If this is in fact the case, there is a bug in each version of the MS C ...
    (comp.lang.cpp)