Re: How to find Me in a library procedure

Tech-Archive recommends: Repair Windows Errors & Optimize Windows Performance

Hi Armin,

"Armin Zingler" <az.nospam@xxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message news:eHk5djoXIHA.4808@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

So what? I made a general statement that a procedure should be an encapsulated task. If he has to change anything, be it so. He wanted a suggestion. I gave one.


I suggest you look at my original response and the posters original question. (the OP asked about the stack state)




You should have mentioned that you meant a /combination/ of extension methods and interfaces. As long as I am the author of the class, I extend the class by adding instance members, not by adding extension methods. Extension methods make sense if you are not the author. Obviously he is the author, otherwise he couldn't pass "Me".



Again, as I have pointed out, inheritance only works if you are the author of the common base class . With controls that is rarely the case.



Well if you do understand, I don't see why you seem to be getting so
bent out of shape. The criticisms I put forward are valid. You in
response to that attacked the idea of criticizing something. Draconian at best.

Not at all. Just was surprised about your criticism of a valid solution made in advance. Completely unnecessary IMO.



Well this is a public forum, and I'd expect people to learn and share ideas, not just settle for the first one that is put forward.



[...]

Um.. yes.



Say what ?




> No need to elaborte on this further. I do see the cons of my
> solution, but I still think that Inheritance is probably the best
> approach in the situation. I suggest: Let's wait (if) what the OP
> says (anything).
>

Great. Then why the response when I did post the cons which you
clearly had not ?

My lack of knowledge of the English language disables me to understand this, but don't bother...



Can't help you there.














.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: How to find Me in a library procedure
    ... methods and interfaces. ... As long as I am the author of the class, I extend the class by adding instance members, not by adding extension methods. ... The criticisms I put forward are valid. ... Just was surprised about your criticism of a valid solution made in advance. ...
    (microsoft.public.dotnet.languages.vb)
  • where does Charlene supervise so genuinely, whenever Rashid bangs the gross policeman very please
    ... The remainders, diseases, and criticisms are all ... Well, formats eliminate at times prime employments, unless they're ... Karim instead. ... suppresses in response to the planet. ...
    (comp.arch)
  • Re: Adding Javadoc to Netbeans 6.1
    ... Particularly since a certain embarrassment that befell Sony a couple of years ago. ... On a side note, in your two posts in response to mine, but especially in this second one, I detected a distinct tone of hostility, and even derision. ... And even if so, I think that those criticisms were valid and constructive, whereas your responding to them by being rude to me most certainly was not. ...
    (comp.lang.java.programmer)
  • Re: Re: dont even try to revise the supports thus, harm them carelessly
    ... Don't relate no longer while you're taking in response to a intermediate ... councillor on to the movement. ... the criticisms often ... If you'll picture Wayne's memory with kms, ...
    (sci.crypt)
  • Re: How to get a paper published as an independent unknown
    ... I'll add that in sales, we answer objections with canned answers, and ... You might consider an appendix of criticisms and responses, ... response, and whether your response resolved the criticism would be ... All this is hard work, of a different style from the ...
    (sci.physics.research)