Re: A re-announce on GC's defects



Born wrote:
GC is really garbage itself

Hey, I have a lot of patience, but I'm sorry... when someone starts a
post with a patently moronic statement like that, well, I conclude that
that person is a moron.

GC is worthless garbage? That must be why Java was a flash in the pan.
Hardly anyone uses Java. As one poster said, "Oh wait."

Not that I consider one study a definitive conclusion, but the one
cited here

http://www.eweek.com/article2/0,1895,2065392,00.asp

says,

"Java now holds the market penetration lead at 45 percent, followed by
C/C++ at 40 percent, and C# at 32 percent."

(Yes, I realize that the numbers add up to more than 100%... I assume
that that is because some shops, like ours, use more than one
language.)

I'm not game to draw any solid conclusions from these numbers, but a
general conclusion is fair game: for a memory management method that is
"garbage itself" it's doing very well. I don't think it's out of line
to say that more than half of all new software is being written using a
garbage-collected language.

Given this, I think that there are only two possible conclusions that
you can draw:

1. Half of the programmers in the world are benighted idiots who have
not yet attained the lofty heights of intellectual superiority that you
now enjoy. They would be using C++ if only they would realize The
Truth.

2. You're missing something.

Personally, I vote for door #2.

.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Optimise my ray tracer
    ... My Java implementation of the ray tracer is slow because I represented 3D ... garbage collection and functional programming style. ... collected languages, it is a shame that comparable performance can only be ...
    (comp.lang.java.programmer)
  • Re: Allocation outside garbage-collected heap
    ... > use those objects in Java I need to allocate it using AllocObject ... if you want to use it as an object in java you do. ... there are definitely applications where current java garbage ...
    (comp.lang.java.programmer)
  • Re: how many objects r eligible for garbage Collection ?
    ... Java 6 does collect objects where the only references have no further use. ... It is possible to observe this behaviour if you also have a weak reference to the 'garbage'. ... public void add(boolean nullify, boolean gc, boolean sleep) ...
    (comp.lang.java.programmer)
  • Re: Stupidest game of the month. 11 move Mate.
    ... avoid the draw anyway. ... I didn't measure exactly but I think Micro-Max was taking ... java threads that were running on the same machine. ... So GetClub is 4 times slow. ...
    (rec.games.chess.computer)
  • Re: Wieso noch C
    ... Als besonders mythenbehaftete Formen der Garbage Collection ist Visual Basic ... Bei Java wird gern der Finalizer von Objekten mit einer Aufräumaktion ... Der Garbage Collector von Java macht dem jedoch einen Strich durch die ... Die meinsten Programmierer wissen nicht mal, ...
    (de.comp.lang.misc)

Loading