Re: Reading great code

Tech-Archive recommends: Repair Windows Errors & Optimize Windows Performance

Kevin Spencer wrote:
I use it as a hobbyist. As I said, professionally I don't use C#. I'm not aware of any mission-critical applications that use .NET (or Mono), and the more critical applications use specialist operating systems (and compilers, and libraries) or no operating system at all (except perhaps as a loader), for just the reason you've spotted.

I'm afraid you're just plain wrong here. First of all, if you use *any* programming language above the Assembler level (which is, in fact, a library of reusable machine code), you use various libraries (DLLs), as well as your own custom code. The C language, for example, can't be used without at the very least the stdio library. C++ has the MFC library. Java has the J2SE library. The .Net platform is no different.

None of those languages is used for the sort of application I am dealing with, at least not at the higher criticalities. Nor are their associated libraries. And even when the languages used do have code libraries available, those libraries are generally not used unless they have been specifically designed with mission-critical applications in mind.

Second, there are *lots* of mission-critical applications out there written with the .Net platform. It is not a prototyping platform, any more than Java is a prototyping platform.

I'm not suggesting that .net is a prototyping platform; I know it's better than that. There's a distinction between real-world applications in general and mission-critical applications in particular. I'm dealing with applications that can kill a few hundred people at a time if they go wrong (and I work with people who are dealing with applications that can kill a few thousand people at a time). I'm not aware of .net being in used that sort of application, and I'd be very worried if it were, not because there's anything wrong with .net but because that's not what ..net is designed to be good at. There's a lot of complexity in .net and in MS Windows which gives the richness that AFAICS is a great help in the cost-effective development of commercial-strength applications but which is a problem for mission-critical. The hazards can't be completely eliminated, but the more of them that are taken out of the system the better.

Yes, as soon as I use a compiler I'm doing some code reuse courtesy of the compiler's code generator. I was careful not to say that there was no reuse, just that it's treated with a great deal of caution. Oh, and on the more critical projects I've worked on, the I/O routines /have/ been custom-written in assembler. Before you ask, the correctness of the microprocessor is a continuing issue, but it's a question of eliminating unnecessary risks and being aware of (and managing) the risks that are left.
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Can MS listen to customers?
    ... IE is comprised of a set of libraries that other applications use. ... a HUGE portion of even a minimal install of Windows (or even in ... For Windows, Notepad, Paint, IE, OE, msconfig, Wordpad, Hearts, NT ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.general)
  • [Full-Disclosure] Overflow in SunRPC-derived XDR libraries
    ... Applications using vulnerable implementations of SunRPC-derived XDR ... BSD-derived libraries with XDR/RPC routines ... Note that this vulnerability is similar to, but distinct from, ... Because SunRPC-derived XDR libraries are used by a variety of vendors ...
    (Full-Disclosure)
  • Re: Reading great code
    ... the more critical applications use specialist operating systems (and ... compilers, and libraries) or no operating system at all (except perhaps as ... of reusable machine code), you use various libraries, as well as your ... there are *lots* of mission-critical applications out there written ...
    (microsoft.public.dotnet.languages.csharp)
  • Re: Reading great code
    ... not aware of any mission-critical applications that use .NET, ... and libraries) or no operating system at all (except perhaps ... The C language, for example, can't be used ... more than Java is a prototyping platform. ...
    (microsoft.public.dotnet.languages.csharp)
  • Re: [Lit.] Buffer overruns
    ... >>safe application difficult and secure applications impossible. ... >>libraries can be shrunk to fit and C's RTL is one of those. ... applications it might be (I suspect the performance-sensitive apps are ...
    (sci.crypt)