Re: COM+ vs .Net Remoting vs...

Tech-Archive recommends: Repair Windows Errors & Optimize Windows Performance

Hello Aleksandr,

Im not sure if it really helps you in that. Didn't standard NLB
redirect your calls? Why to write custom one?

AS> Because customer doesn't allow to use it... or to use any other
AS> third-party (free or not, Microsoft's - too) component, product
AS>

What do u mean? NLB is the component of the windows 2003 server, btw MS ships Cluster Server

AS> I wanted to see comparision of using COM+ and Remoting not from
AS> performance point of view but from features side.

I'm not good with remoting and always use COM+ for 2 reason: performance and supporting next version of commutication technologies.
COM+ is declarative technology, all features are set with attributes. Remoting request hardcoding.
Next version of communications - WCF gives COM+ full support. Remoting is out of this game

Why don't connect to the managed custom COM+ component, that will
serve as TCPGateway and will redirect calls futher. It's facage
class in your solution

AS> As I know network connection to COM+ is allowed since COM+ 1.5
AS> (Server 2003) or not? And ahy this is better then Web service TCP
AS> service?

What do u mean with COM+ network connection? You can use
DCOM/Remoting to interact with your COM+

AS> It's interesting. May be I looked bad - where this could be
AS> described?

What exactly? How to interact with COM+ by DCOM? It's set in the proxy that u create in COM+ Adming MMC window

AS> Yes, this is in case of failover cluster, but we want to consider
AS> another type of cluster (it seems grid) - cluster with operation
AS> distributing, for example

Think aboup p2p connections, I would choose this way, due to good support p2p in vista
You need scrutinize how u will find nodes in your grid and register new node to be find

---
WBR,
Michael Nemtsev :: blog: http://spaces.msn.com/laflour

"At times one remains faithful to a cause only because its opponents do not cease to be insipid." (c) Friedrich Nietzsche


.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: HA CMP Resources synchronisation failed
    ... CLUSTER VERIFY OR SYNCH FAILS WITH MSG INDICATING ... The cluster.log log file has already been redirected via ... If you wish to redirect this log again, ... Remove tabs between fields of /etc/syslog.conf file entries. ...
    (AIX-L)
  • Re: Singleton heartbeat monitoring
    ... remoting even when you opened particular ports and redirect the network ...
    (microsoft.public.dotnet.framework.remoting)
  • Re: File Server Active/Passive to Active/Active
    ... DFS Stand Alone is Cluster aware. ... DFS Domain Root already can be replicated ... > there a redirect that sends them directly to W2K3FS01A and that's it. ...
    (microsoft.public.windows.server.clustering)
  • Re: dcom vs com+ vs remoting
    ... scale much faster and higher than remoting (I've used both quite a ... >> probably give you better performance and remoting will be easier to ... >> cluster your web and business logic tiers). ... >> Allen Anderson ...
    (microsoft.public.dotnet.framework.remoting)